Welcome


Thank you for visiting our new forum! To start posting again please follow the link below to create a new password. First time forum users please follow the link to register. CFI thanks you for continuing the discussion on evidence-based thinking and humanist values.

Riding Bike to Star Trek TNG


Forums Forums Entertainment and Pop Culture Riding Bike to Star Trek TNG

This topic contains 12 replies, has 3 voices, and was last updated by  TimB 2 days, 15 hours ago.

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #309573

    3point14rat
    Participant

    I watched episodes 7 and 8 last night. My legs were dead by the end and I could hardly get up the stairs. But that’s why I do it.

    The quality (or lack thereof)  in those shows is mind boggling.

    Here are totally subjective rankings out of 10:

    • Wardrobe = 6
    • Set = 2
    • Acting = ranges from 1 to 6
    • Cinematography = 4
    • Script = 6
    • Special Effects = 0.7
    • Scientific Accuracy = 1
    • Overall Impression = 2

    So why do I love it so much?!?!?

    #309650

    TimB
    Participant

    Probably you have conditioned yourself to like it by pairing watching it with the self production of endogenous opiates.

    #309697

    Advocatus
    Participant

    I remember the episodes by title and not by the number, so you would have to refresh my memory of which episodes you’re talking about.  Although I do recall that the first season of TNG did not especially appeal to me.  It wasn’t until the second season when Katherine Pulaski joined that I started enjoying it.

    #309839

    3point14rat
    Participant

    “Lonely Among Us” and “Justice” are the names of the two NTG episodes.  I’m going through them all in order, so I had watched all the previous ones before watching them, and have watched the next two since.

    I also watch movies for a change of pace from Star Trek, and yesterday was “American History X”. I had seen it many years ago and didn’t remember most of the details. It’s alright with good acting. It’s a 6.5/10.

    My wife worked late yesterday and got home around 7:00. She wanted to watch something so we watched “Justice League”. Up until last night I hadn’t seen a superhero movie worth my time in many years… and that’s still true… ugh! They all suck and blow in too many ways to mention. This one gets 2/10, and that’s only because my wife and daughter had a good time watching it.

    #309840

    Advocatus
    Participant

    Yeah, “Lonely Among Us” and “Justice” were both pretty awful.  Although “Justice” did deal with the concept of arbitrary “zero tolerance” laws  that were just handed down from on high as it were, and as such it could have been interesting — in practice it was a pretty silly story.  And those ridiculous costumes the natives wore were the absolute worst.

    I completely agree about the current crop of superhero movies.  I liked “Captain America, the First Avenger”, but they went down hill from there.  And the DC movies are worse than the Marvel ones.  Only recently did I watch the Dark Knight movie, the one with Heath Ledger as the Joker, and the violence was so disgusting I changed the channel halfway through it.  From now on, I am not the slightest bit impressed when I hear that someone won an Academy Award.

    #309841

    3point14rat
    Participant

    Yeah, “Lonely Among Us” and “Justice” were both pretty awful.  Although “Justice” did deal with the concept of arbitrary “zero tolerance” laws  that were just handed down from on high as it were, and as such it could have been interesting — in practice it was a pretty silly story.  And those ridiculous costumes the natives wore were the absolute worst.

    I’m pretty sure the reason I love NTG so much is because I identify with the morality humans finally arrived at. Every episode is a blunt morality lesson, and in spite of the many terrible things about the show, I like the feeling I get when seeing my morality being played out.

    The characters are all super simple but lots of fun to watch (both Deanna Troi’s mom, Lwaxana, and Q, are a total hoot whenever they make an appearance.)

    I completely agree about the current crop of superhero movies.  I liked “Captain America, the First Avenger”, but they went down hill from there.  And the DC movies are worse than the Marvel ones.  Only recently did I watch the Dark Knight movie, the one with Heath Ledger as the Joker, and the violence was so disgusting I changed the channel halfway through it.  From now on, I am not the slightest bit impressed when I hear that someone won an Academy Award.

    The CGI has been way over the top for many years now. It would be interesting to see if Hollywood knew how to make an action movie without a green-screen for the action shots- the director would probably be clueless as to what to do.

    Lately, story and acting have been a distant second and third consideration when making most action movies, but since I only care about those two aspects of a movie, I honestly haven’t been interested in watching one for at least a decade.

    #309983

    Advocatus
    Participant

    I’m with you about the morality of the series.  For some reason a lot of people complain about the characters being “too perfect”, but to me that was the whole point.  Just the other day I heard about a university that suspended all of its fraternities and sororities because a student was killed in a hazing ritual.  I hope that by the 24th century, humans will have learned to be more mindful and self-disciplined.

    I was trying to think of which episode from the first season was my favorite and it was difficult to pick one.  I suppose it would be “11001001”, if only for the appearance of Minuet.  “Neutral Zone” was a good one, too.

    #310019

    3point14rat
    Participant

    It’s been many years (mid 90’s) since I watched any of these, and the names of the episodes meant nothing way back then so they’re meaningless to me now. As I watch them I see the names of episodes, but I’ve already forgotten the few I’ve seen.

    I love any with Lore (Data’s ‘brother’), Q, or focus especially heavily on one of the main characters. It’s been so long since I last watched them that I forget almost every episode. A few specific scenes are stuck in my memory, but remembering an entire episode… not even close.

    Tonight I’ll watch two more (unless the ‘honey-do’ list has some new and urgent additions). Having these to watch is great incentive to get my exercise, so in a few weeks I might be up to three episodes.

    #310161

    Advocatus
    Participant

    If I remember the list of episodes I consulted, the next two in line would be “We’ll Always Have Paris” and “Conspiracy”.  Those were pretty good, too.  I saw the first one the other day on BBC America.  One interesting thing to notice is that at one point, at Troi’s suggestion, Picard visits the holodeck in order to work out a problem which is nagging at him.  The characters he meets there just happen to be playing out a scenario which perfectly coincides with the problem which is on his mind — implying that the holodeck doubles as a therapeutic tool, somehow reading your mind and furnishing appropriate interaction.  In later episodes, this concept seems to have been discarded for the most part.

    #310286

    TimB
    Participant

    Maybe Trois just secretly placed the therapeutic scenario in the holodeck, just before she suggested that Picard go there.

    #310362

    Advocatus
    Participant

    That’s possible except that she didn’t know the nature of his conflict; she only sensed that he had one and offered to talk it over with him.  Picard declined (this was the first season, remember; by season seven he wouldn’t have hesitated) and only later decided to visit the holodeck.

    Anyway I stand corrected.  The next two episodes in sequence would have been “The Battle” and “Haven” — two fairly humdrum episodes in my opinion.  Not bad, but not exactly memorable either.

    #310381

    TimB
    Participant

    Advo, You’re not one of those Trekky people are you?

    Anyway, the holodeck is obviously a very powerful AI  devoted to its tasks of entertainment, education, training, etc.  (and perhaps, also, psychologically therapeutic interventions).  So here’s what could have happened.  You as an audience member were shown enough for you to detect that aspect of the holodeck’s function.  However, for that function of the holodeck, to be effective, it must remain unknown to the crew members that they are being therapized. So no one ever knows about it, or talks about it, or even realizes it when it’s happening, as it is quite subtle.

     

    #310385

    TimB
    Participant

    Wasn’t there an episode in which the Enterprise, along with the holodeck as a critical component, became sentient?  There was a train ride going on holograpically, and members of the crew would go into it to try to figure out what was going on. I don’t recall for sure if it was a TNG episode or one of the other series incarnations.

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.